A CSA score (Compliance, Safety, and Accountability) is one of the most important factors in the trucking industry. It affects carriers, drivers, and overall safety performance. The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) calculates CSA scores based on violations, inspections, and accident history. A low CSA score signals good safety practices, leading to lower insurance costs, fewer audits, and a strong industry reputation.
On the other hand, a high CSA score can lead to serious problems, including frequent inspections, increased insurance premiums, and even restrictions on operations. If a carrier’s safety violations keep increasing, they may even lose business opportunities since brokers and shippers prefer to work with safer carriers.
To keep a good CSA score, carriers need to train their drivers, prevent violations, and use reliable electronic logging devices (ELDs). Many violations happen due to aggressive driving and incorrect logs, so carriers must build a safety-first culture to stay compliant.
Below, we’ll explore strategies to improve CSA scores, avoid penalties, and highlight how companies maintain compliance and safety.
A low CSA score helps carriers avoid frequent audits, penalties, and insurance rate increases. A high score, on the other hand, can lead to business disruptions and increased operating costs. However, there are clear steps carriers can take to improve their CSA scores and stay compliant.
Effective Ways To Maintain Low CSA Score
Emphasizing a Safety-First Culture
One of the most effective ways to lower a CSA score is by making safety a core part of company culture. Drivers should understand that safety isn’t just about avoiding violations—it’s about protecting their own lives, the lives of others on the road, and the company’s reputation.
Carriers can build a safety-first culture by setting clear expectations, rewarding good behavior, and holding drivers accountable. A bonus program that rewards drivers for staying violation-free for a certain period can encourage responsible driving.
Since aggressive driving is a leading cause of CSA score increases, tracking driver habits with telematics and providing targeted coaching can reduce violations. Carriers should also conduct regular safety meetings to reinforce proper driving techniques and compliance.
Encouraging open communication between drivers and management helps identify safety concerns early. Drivers who feel supported are more likely to report hazards, follow policies, and drive responsibly.
Hiring and Training Great Drivers
A company’s CSA score depends heavily on the quality of its drivers. The hiring process should focus on selecting experienced, safety-conscious drivers who have a clean record. Background checks should include driving history, accident reports, and past CSA violations.
Once hired, drivers should go through a structured training program that covers FMCSA regulations, defensive driving techniques, hours-of-service rules, and proper vehicle inspections. Many violations happen not because drivers intend to break the rules, but simply because they don’t fully understand them.
Continuous training and coaching help drivers stay updated on industry changes and best practices. Some carriers offer quarterly safety workshops and online training sessions to ensure compliance.
Investing in Reliable ELDs
Electronic Logging Devices (ELDs) are a critical tool for CSA compliance. However, not all ELDs work the same way. Some lose data in areas with poor network coverage, leading to incomplete logs that can result in violations. Carriers should invest in high-quality, FMCSA-approved ELDs that ensure accurate tracking.
Drivers must also be trained properly on how to use ELDs correctly. Many violations happen simply because a driver forgets to update their log or doesn’t know how to make corrections. Making sure every driver understands how to log hours properly helps prevent unnecessary CSA penalties.
By focusing on safety culture, quality hiring, and proper ELD use, carriers can improve CSA scores and maintain compliance.
Avoiding High CSA Scores and Their Consequences
A high CSA score can cause major problems for carriers, affecting everything from insurance costs to business reputation. A poor safety record can lead to frequent FMCSA audits, increased inspections, and even operational restrictions.
How High CSA Scores Impact Carriers
The higher a carrier’s CSA score, the more inspections and audits they can expect from the FMCSA. This can cause delays, additional costs, and disruptions to operations.
Insurance companies also look at CSA scores when determining premium rates. A high CSA score often means higher insurance costs, making it more expensive for the carrier to keep their fleet on the road.
In extreme cases, if a carrier has persistent violations, the FMCSA may conduct a compliance review. If safety issues are not addressed, the carrier could be issued an Out-of-Service Order, temporarily or permanently shutting down operations.
Strategies to Keep CSA Scores Low
Maintaining a low CSA score is essential for long-term success in the trucking industry. Carriers that focus on preventing violations before they happen can avoid costly penalties, reduce insurance costs, and attract better business opportunities.
Monitoring Driver Performance
A major factor in CSA scores is driver behavior. Even experienced drivers can develop unsafe habits, so regular performance tracking and feedback are important.
Many companies use telematics systems to track real-time driving data, such as:
- Speeding incidents
- Hard braking or sudden stops
- Lane drifting
- Excessive idle time
By analyzing this data, carriers can identify risky drivers early and offer additional training or coaching to help them improve.
Strict Safety Policies and Accountability
Having clear and enforced safety policies is key to keeping CSA scores low. Carriers should implement:
- Strict policies for reckless driving
- Routine safety training and refresher courses
- Performance-based rewards for safe drivers
Drivers should be reminded that every violation adds up and can impact their career and earning potential. Ensuring that management holds all drivers accountable helps build a consistent safety culture.
Fleet Maintenance and Inspections
Many CSA violations come from preventable vehicle issues. Carriers should schedule regular maintenance checks to ensure their trucks meet all FMCSA safety requirements.
Common maintenance-related CSA violations include:
- Brake system failures
- Tire tread violations
- Broken headlights or turn signals
- Faulty steering systems
A preventive maintenance program can help carriers avoid these violations and keep their fleet running safely.
Accurate Record-Keeping and Compliance
One of the biggest mistakes carriers make is failing to properly maintain driver logs and safety records. CSA scores are directly impacted by hours-of-service violations, missing inspection reports, and incomplete logbooks.
Carriers should:
- Train drivers on accurate record-keeping
- Ensure ELDs are working properly
- Perform internal audits to catch errors before the FMCSA does
By focusing on compliance, training, and monitoring, carriers can avoid CSA penalties and maintain a strong reputation.
A Carrier’s Approach to CSA Compliance
For trucking companies, maintaining a low CSA score isn’t just about avoiding penalties—it’s about ensuring long-term success, reducing costs, and keeping operations running smoothly. Carriers that focus on safety, compliance, and proactive measures can prevent unnecessary violations and improve overall fleet performance.
A strong CSA compliance strategy includes:
- Hiring experienced, safety-conscious drivers who follow regulations and avoid violations.
- Using reliable ELDs to ensure accurate hours-of-service tracking and prevent log discrepancies.
- Implementing strict policies against aggressive driving to minimize safety risks.
- Providing ongoing safety training so drivers stay informed about FMCSA rules and best practices.
- Investing in well-maintained vehicles to prevent maintenance-related violations and roadside inspections.
- Monitoring driver performance through telematics and coaching programs to reduce risky behavior.
By prioritizing compliance and safety, carriers can maintain a strong reputation, lower insurance costs, and avoid unnecessary audits. Companies that take a proactive approach to CSA score management create a safer work environment for drivers and increase business opportunities with shippers and brokers who prefer low-risk carriers.
Final Thoughts
A low CSA score is critical for carriers to stay compliant, lower insurance costs, and avoid frequent audits. Carriers can achieve this by hiring great drivers, providing ongoing training, investing in reliable ELDs, and preventing violations.
By staying committed to safety and compliance, carriers can protect their drivers, improve their reputation, and ensure long-term business success.
Answer 5 simple questions to request a